Adios, OPFOR
Readers, it's time for me to move on from OPFOR. A sincere thanks to all of you who have read daily, added us to your feeds, commented, discussed, argued, complained, and otherwise participated in a wonderful four year chat on the state of all things military. I'll be leaving the site in the most capable hands of LtCol P and our cast of outstanding military professionals (they're much better bloggers than this guy anyway) -- though we'll certainly need a voice to fill the Air Force vacancy (take note, Col P!).
I'll be separating from the Air Force and moving on to some exciting new things in DC, where I'll continue filling cyberspace with my peculiar brand of hot air, as well as exercising my 2nd Amendment rights -frequently, I hope!-with the good Colonel.
It's been a real honor to blog for Military.com, alongside their terrific team of bloggers. Many thanks to Christian Lowe, Ward Carroll, Chris Michel and the entire Military.com team for picking up a dopey little blogspot milblog called The Officers Club and helping turn it into something great.
I hope each and every one of you continue reading, laughing, and soaking in all the wealth of experience our bloggers bring to the table. Sincere thanks, farewell, and best wishes to all that I've been honored to call our loyal readers.
In the Bonds,
John Noonan
Marines Gone "Rogue"??
"Or Leading the Way?"
"DELARAM, AFGHANISTAN -- Home to a dozen truck stops and a few hundred family farms bounded by miles of foreboding desert, this hamlet in southwestern Afghanistan is far from a strategic priority for senior officers at the international military headquarters in Kabul. One calls Delaram, a day's drive from the nearest city, "the end of the Earth." Another deems the area "unrelated to our core mission" of defeating the Taliban by protecting Afghans in their cities and towns.
"U.S. Marine commanders have a different view of the dusty, desolate landscape that surrounds Delaram. They see controlling this corner of remote Nimruz province as essential to promoting economic development and defending the more populated parts of southern Afghanistan."
I'll refrain from comment-- you be the judge!
A short excerpt from New Dawn.
Within hours of the Blackwater ambush on the last day of March 2004, the Marines moved to cordon off the entire city. Inside, the enemy prepared for the inevitable assault. Major General James Mattis and Lieutenant General James Conway, however, recommended restraint. The Assistant Division Commander, Brigadier General John Kelly, sought to temper America’s response in the Division’s daily report:

We have a well thought out campaign plan that considers the Fallujah problem across its very complicated spectrum.
Read More »
This plan most certainly includes kinetic action, but going overly kinetic at this juncture plays into the hands of the opposition in exactly the way they assume we will. This is why they shoot and throw hand grenades out of crowds, to bait us into overreaction…We should not fall victim to their hopes for a vengeful response. To react to this provocation, as heinous as it is, will likely negate the efforts of the 82nd Airborne Division paid for in blood, and complicate our campaign plan, which we have not yet been given the opportunity to implement.
Counterinsurgency forces have learned many times in the past that the desire to demonstrate force and resolve has long term and generally negative implications, and destabilize rather than stabilize the environment.
The Marine commanders did not want to further disenfranchise the people of Fallujah. They told their corps commander, U. S. Army Lieutenant General Ricardo Sanchez, that they could find the perpetrators of the ambush and bring them to justice within two weeks. Sanchez passed on the Marines’ recommendation. Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, however, was not impressed with the suggestion for a tempered response and ordered the Marines to attack. Conway and Mattis had delivered their recommendation as to how they thought they should respond, but when they received their orders, they—like any good Marines—unflinchingly obeyed them.
The Fight Begins: Operation Vigilant Resolve
On April 5, 2004, U.S. Marines charged into the city, destroying enemy positions and killing every enemy combatant who stood in their path. One of the Marines driving into Fallujah was Gunnery Sergeant Nicholas Popaditch. Angered by the heinous murders of the Blackwater contractors and the insurgents’ claims that Fallujah was the graveyard of Americans,“Gunny Pop” couldn’t wait to get into the fight…
Read Gunny Pop’s story and those of dozens more American heroes in “New Dawn: The Battles for Fallujah,” coming to a bookstore near you in May, 2010. Visit www.fallujahbook.com to learn more about New Dawn and Richard S. Lowry’s coming book tour.
« Close It
A Mother Remember Her Son Lt Col Rupert Thorneloe
From today's Sunday Telegraph, "Mother's Day: Today Will be Hard," a mother's thoughts of her son killed in Afghanistan.
We were all so proud of Rupert. He was a wonderful son, brother, husband and father, though frantically untidy. In other ways he was very organised but his filthy jeans were always left on the stairs for mummy to pick up. He was also very good with people, which made him a very fine soldier. John and I hadn’t realised quite how highly regarded he was – as parents you don’t – until we read the obituaries, and heard the tributes at his funeral. General Dannatt called him “an outstanding commanding officer and a born leader”; Des Browne, with whom he had worked at the MOD, called him “the best of the best”.
5 Myths About Afghanistan
From today's Washington Post, "Five Myths About the War in Afghanistan." Having been a Red Team Leader, this article represents the type of thinking Red Teams should be providing to their Commands, questioning assumptions.
Major John Moder '98-- Heard from Today!
The ever-vigilant Brother Rat BullNav, perched high up in a virtual crow's nest scanning the mil news wavetops, zapped this great piece of news to us:
MarSOC officer awarded Bronze Star
Staff report
Posted : Friday Mar 12, 2010 9:37:04 EST
The officer in charge of Marine Corps Forces Special Operations Command’s assessment and selection received a Bronze Star with “V” device on Tuesday for his actions in Afghanistan.
On May 30, 2008, Maj. John A. Moder, 36, repeatedly exposed himself to Taliban sharpshooters and rocket-propelled grenades during a firefight in the Garmsir district of Helmand province. Then-Capt. Moder was serving as commanding officer of Charlie Company, Battalion Landing Team, 1st Battalion, 6th Marines, with the 24th Marine Expeditionary Unit.
Over the course of a 14-hour fight, Moder “fearlessly” led his Marines from bunker to bunker, killing several insurgents with an M240G machine gun and an M4 assault rifle in support of Operation Azada Wosa.
“Calm and courageous under fire, he remained at the front of his company in constant contact with insurgent fighters,” according to the citation. “He was conspicuous throughout in his leadership and heroism. Capt. Moder’s resolute leadership and courage in the face of a determined enemy reflected great credit upon him and were in keeping with the highest traditions of the Marine Corps and the United States Naval Service.”
Moder, who has deployed four times since Sept. 11, 2001, received his commission in 1998 after graduating from the Virginia Military Institute in Lexington, Va.

Well done, Marine. You make us proud!
Firearms Friday: Safety, Safety, Safety
A tragedy barely averted near Quantico, with my editorial comments in [brackets]:
"Woman Hurt in Bizarre Gun Accident
"DUMFRIES, Va. - A shotgun went off [no, it did not!] as a man was practicing loading it [with no regard for Rule 3] inside his home in Dumfries. The buck shot traveled through his house and into his neighbor's home [no shit! it tends to do that], injuring the woman. She is expected to live [thank God]."
The article, if correct, states that this is the THIRD time the man has discharged a firearm negligently. If those are indeed the facts-- it's hard to know for sure because the article is not well written-- then I'm sorry but some sort of action is warranted. (I'll be happy to dial it back in case the facts are otherwise.) For that guy, a retired Marine who should know better, "safety" is a little switch somewhere near the trigger and not a constant mindset.
This should be a good object lesson for all of us not to fall into the same negligent habits. Safety, safety, safety.
Development of Counter Insurgency
There is a new blog section at Washington Post, the Political Bookworm, today there was a guest blog by Historian Mark Perry in which how the first steps were taken in turning insurgents to the US side. One of the actors in this drama was my Brother Rat, Colonel John "JC" Coleman USMC, then Chief of Staff of the I MEF Camp Pendleton California. Here is the blog, "Time to Talk to Terrorists." Rah Va MIl 76 76 76.
Women of Hope
Here's a slightly late, but I believe wholly appropriate, nod to International Womens Day: the Women of Hope Project.
"The Women of Hope Project is an organization by women for women to restore hope and dignity to women who have been oppressed and denied personal freedom, health, opportunity, and respect. We hope to create a sisterhood to encourage and provide resources to help these women recover from the traumatic devastation of 23 years of war."
Sound a little too touchy-feely for us? You might think again, because I have seen the WoHP at work in Kabul, and I think it is one of the best NGOs on deck today, and also one of the most effective movements for positive change. If we want a stable, prosperous, functional Afghanistan, it will be organizations like Betsy's WoHP that effect the change, one family at a time. I used to chat with her every friday morning at the Camp Eggers bazaar, and became deeply impressed with how much she has done, starting from scratch.
"With the airline industry in limbo, Betsy took a year’s leave and made a trip to Afghanistan. She saw the plight of thousands of women and children who were left to fend for themselves in a male dominated society that was bereft of able bodied men to take care of them after 25 years of war. While she returned several times with donations to help the women, she knew that this was not going to fix the long term problem of helping the women to learn to support themselves. After many prayers and sleepless nights trying to figure out what to do, Betsy hit upon an idea that she thought might solve their problem. ..."
One of their signature projects is the bottle burqa, which is a great triple-poke in the eye for the Taliban. The folks at GOP Counterculture blogged about the one I sent to them-- yes, I'm the "good friend just returned from Afghanistan", and Mudville picked it up too:

Of course, this isn't the only thing they make and it's really a small part of their offerings, but it appeals to my sense of humor and defiance. Folks, if we want to win the campaign in Afghanistan and help them (re)build their nation, we will need to support organizations like WoHP. Betsy is doing things no military or governmental agency has done or can do. Visit her site, and give a little to the very best of causes.
Fallujah -- the real Hurt Locker

To the cast and crew of “The Hurt Locker,” Congratulations and thank you for bringing this powerful message to the American public about an heroic EOD team working in Baghdad. This film provides a microcosm of what it is like to be fighting a 21st Century war in the Middle East. Imagine The Hurt Locker on an epic scale.
Read More »
In Fallujah in 2004, the soldiers and Marines were not able to call in Explosive Ordnance Disposal teams to diffuse IEDs. In Fallujah, the soldiers and Marines were forced to drop bombs on urban minefields. On one occasion a string of IEDs two blocks long was detonated by a single GPS-guided bomb.
In Fallujah a handful of soldiers were not pinned down by a single enemy sniper. In Fallujah American M1 tanks were pinned down by riflemen and grenadiers lurking in every window. In Fallujah, 8000 American troops were locked in mortal combat with 4000 diehard jihadists for several weeks.
In Fallujah, over 100 American soldiers, sailors and Marines were killed during the 2004 fighting and hundreds more were wounded. Many lives were lost and everyone’s life was changed forever. Nine Navy Crosses and twenty-two Silver Stars were awarded for gallantry during Operation Phantom Fury—many posthumously.
Read the true stories of American heroes fighting the most intense battle since Hue City, Vietnam in New Dawn: The Battles for Fallujah, available in bookstores in May, 2010.
« Close It
Captain Queeg Is Alive and Relieved
Pat Lang at Sic Semper Tyrannis has had a very interesting discussion on the relief by the Navy of Captain Holly Graf as Commanding Officer of the USS Cowpens. There are several embedded links in the Sic Semper Tyrannis I would suggest all to follow those as they paint a very disturbing picture of life under her command.
"Yet voters still came"
Iraq takes another step forward.
"Polls closed across Iraq on Sunday as the war-weary population awaits results from the national election that will decide the future of the country's still-fragile democracy.
"The election tested the mettle of the country's shaky security as insurgents killed 31 people across Iraq, unleashing a barrage of mortars intent on disrupting the historic day.
"About 19 million Iraqis were eligible to vote on a government that will oversee the withdrawal of U.S. forces. The election is critical in determining whether Iraq can overcome the jagged sectarian divisions that have defined it since the U.S.-led invasion in 2003."
Imperfect and marred by violence in places; however, that country (so far) refuses to quit. The Iraqis might march/lurch/step/stagger, but it's always forward. They are building that rarest of commodities in the Mideast-- a tradition of open elections that happen on time.
Imagine that.
Good for them. We wish them nothing but the best, because a functional stable prosperous Iraq with enduring representative government is good for the Iraqis, good for the Mideast, good for us and good for the world.
Firearms Friday: What, Only 21 Countries??
"USA Gun Owners Buy 14 Million Plus Guns In 2009 – More Than 21 of the Worlds Standing Armies Combined"
OK, once you look at the stats, it ain't a bad showing. I was pleased to have done my little part. :-)
Good work, fellow Americans! Keep it up.
Freaks, Weirdos and Yahoos
A big HOO-RAH is due to the good men and women of the PFPA for doing their part in ensuring domestic tranquility and providing for the common defense. Good for them, and I'll be interested in all of the details as they become available.
On thing is sure-- the shooter was a LEFT WING LOON. MMM has more.
On an entirely separate yet oddly related note, I saw this car yesterday in Reston, VA, while going into a Starbucks (wearing my .45, of course).

Tim Karcher Update

I had the honor of interviewing Lieutenant Colonel Tim Karcher for my upcoming book, New Dawn: The Battles for Fallujah. And then, last summer, I told you about LTC Timothy Karcher when he was severely wounded during an attack on his vehicle in Sadr City. I have followed his incredible journey back to life over these last months. Last week Tim Karcher was invited to speak to ROTC students at Harker Heights High School. Take a few moments to read his message to these young men and women. His words will give you a new outlook on facing adversity.
Read More »
Ladies and Gentlemen, I would like to thank you for the opportunity to speak with you all tonight. I would like to share with you a story that changed my life. It’s a story of adversity, a story of faith, a story of meeting challenges head on. I don’t expect that this story will change your life, but I hope that when I am done speaking with you tonight, you will see that all of us can overcome any challenges that we face in life.
As you can see, I don’t have legs. On the 28th of June of last year, while I was in the midst of my third combat tour in Iraq, my patrol, and more specifically my vehicle, was struck by an Explosively Formed Penetrator, an EFP, which is a shaped-charge designed to blast a hole through the armor of our vehicles. This EFP punched a hole through the passenger door on my vehicle, taking with it my legs.
At the time, my battalion was conducting operations in Sadr City, a slum in northeastern Baghdad, Iraq. This was one of the most troubled areas of Baghdad, and there were a great many insurgents who fought us daily. These insurgents viewed Coalition Forces as occupiers and resisted our efforts to help the people of Iraq. My battalion was not only fighting these insurgents, but we were also trying to help our Iraqi partners develop a working government and capable security force, while attempting to increase essential services for the people of this community of almost two million people. We were really trying to help these people to develop a free, functional government that would provide for the needs of the people.
Unfortunately, the insurgents viewed everything that we did with outright distrust and hatred. They believed that the Coalition was simply trying to install a puppet-government in Iraq, so that the US could exploit the nation of Iraq. The insurgents wanted to be in charge; therefore every good thing that we brought to the people was a threat to their ability to take control of the country. So, they fought us tenaciously.
This brings us to that Sunday morning at the end of June; a day that changed my life. I remember the morning well. I was planning to go to one of our small bases that we shared with Iraqi Army forces, and turn this base over solely to Iraqi control. The current Coalition strategic plan was to reduce the presence of US combat forces in the Iraqi cities, and place the onus of responsibility for securing the Iraqi people squarely on the shoulders of the Iraqi Army and Police. Our forces would be taking a more advisory role, supporting the Iraqi Security Forces. It was an ugly morning; already hot and there was a significant sandstorm blowing throughout Baghdad. I considered staying at my base that morning, because we try to limit non-essential patrols when there are heavy sandstorms, due to our inability to support ground forces with aviation assets, like Unmanned Aerial Vehicles, attack helicopters, or even medical evacuation helicopters. But it was my duty to hand over this base to our Iraqi partners, and if I didn’t do it, one of my company commanders would have to do my job. I have been trained by the military to take my duty seriously, and to accomplish my mission. The famous Confederate General Robert E. Lee once said, “Do your duty in all things. You cannot do more, you should never wish to do less.” So, I decided we’d go, and I’d do my duty. As we prepared to depart our base, I remember asking my security patrol leader, who was concerned that we were patrolling in these challenging conditions, “What’s the worst thing that could happen?”
About 10 minutes into the patrol, we were attacked. My vehicle was hit by four of these EFPs, but the armor stopped three of them from penetrating our vehicle. The fourth penetrator came through the door, and struck my legs. Initially, I thought I had two broken legs and reported that to my crew, as I asked for a report from each member of the vehicle crew. Thank God, the other four members of my crew were fine. Once I received their reports, I looked down at my legs for the first time. My M4 carbine had been blown in half, and at that point I realized that my legs were not broken, but instead blown to pieces. That was kind of surprising, and I updated my crew on my actual status. I remember thinking, “Wow, this is gonna be hard,” thinking that learning to walk again was going to be challenging. At that time, I like to say that I decided to take a break, and I passed out.
Some great Soldiers saved my life that day. They drug me out of the vehicle, stabilized me by slowing the blood pouring out of my legs, and rushed me to our Battalion Aid Station, where our Physician’s Assistant worked feverishly to get me stable enough for an hour long drive to the Combat Support Hospital, or CSH, in Baghdad. At the Baghdad CSH, the doctors performed about eight hours of initial surgery on me to save my life.
I then began the odyssey of being evacuated to the United States. My initial stop was in Landstuhl Germany, where doctors continued to work on me to get me stable enough for the eight-hour flight to the States. A week after I was injured, I arrived at Walter Reed Army Medical Center, in Washington DC. Throughout this week, my wife and daughters were on a roller coaster, receiving reports of my condition from the military and friends who were by my side throughout this ordeal.
I remember bits and pieces of my stay in Germany and the early days at Walter Reed. Even when I got back to the States, I continued to have to fight to survive, returning to the ICU on four occasions, with at least two of those occasions being pretty dicey. I remember thinking at one time, as I was being rushed back to the ICU, “So, this is what it feels like to die.”
I have been told that I am lucky to be alive, that I shouldn’t even be here. I have had many folks tell me how surprised they are by my positive attitude and disposition. Those two comments surprise me.
When people tell me how “lucky” I am to be alive, I laugh. In my personal belief system, luck has nothing to do with why I am here today. In my belief, I am here because it is all a part of my God’s plan for me. In my belief, He took this tragedy, and will make good come of it. He promises to never give me a greater challenge than I can face. I take great comfort from these beliefs. They are my beliefs, and I am in no way trying to force my beliefs on others, so I am not going to dwell on them. But, I’m not lucky to be here, I am blessed to be here.
In regard to people’s surprise at my positive attitude, I will tell you that I believe that one of the only things that you, and only you, can really choose, is how you will confront life’s challenges. In the psychological community, they talk about the “Fight or Flight” syndrome, which is the natural reaction to a surprising adverse encounter; a person can either fight or run away. I see my choices, and anyone else’s, when facing adversity as just that simple; you can accept the situation that you find yourself in and try to make the best of it, or you can crawl into a hole and wallow in self pity. I really belief that one path leads to life, and the other path leads to death.
When a person faces a major trauma or set back in their life, it can be a significant challenge. I literally woke up in the hospital in Landstuhl, Germany, in a medicated haze, not really sure where I was and who the people around me were, to be told by an old friend, who I didn’t even recognize at first, that I had no legs. I admit that it didn’t really sink in at first. As it started to sink in, I remember thinking that my life had just changed forever. Never once though did I think, “Wow, my life is over.” That’s why I always say that this was a life changing experience, not a life ending experience. But simply deciding that it was a life changing experience was my decision, I could have decided that it was a life ending experience, and I probably wouldn’t be here tonight with you all.
Despite making this decision to treat this as a life changing experience, vice a life ending experience, the thought of losing your legs is somewhat traumatic. It is very common, that an experience such as this can affect someone psychologically. This brings us to the subject of grief, and how do we, as people, handle grief?
Again, the Psychological community espouses a concept of the Stages of Grief, first formulated by Dr. Elisabeth Kubler-Ross. According to Dr. Kubler-Ross, human beings handle grief in a five stage process – Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression, and Acceptance. I knew of these stages of grief prior to getting injured, and I fully expected to go through these stages. I expected to not accept that I no longer had legs. I expected to get angry, but I didn’t know who the target of my anger would be, figuring that the insurgents or maybe even Iraqis in general might be a target of my anger, or the people I loved possibly, or maybe even I would be bold enough to be angry at my God. I just wasn’t sure. I wasn’t really sure how I was going to face the Bargaining Stage, because I really didn’t believe that I could roll back time or grow back legs. I felt certain that I understood how the Depression Stage was going to work, with daily pity parties and constant feelings of “Why me?” I could see the end state of Acceptance. I just didn’t know how I was going to work through these stages, or even if I would.
From the moment that I truly comprehended that I had lost my legs, I really believe that I accepted it. I say that “from the moment that I truly comprehended that I had lost my legs,” because I was pretty drugged up and getting me to comprehend any fact was a bit of a challenge. I had to be told things several time, just to get it to sink in. Once it sunk in that I had no legs, I really just accepted that that was going to be the way life was from now on. But I also accepted something even more important.
While I accepted that I no longer had legs, I refused to accept that this was going to end my life, nor even did I plan to let it significantly change my life. I decided that I was going to get healthy, get prosthetics, learn to walk, run, and jump again, and then continue my life almost as it had been. Sure, the way that I did things might be different, but I planned to continue to do whatever I wanted to do. As I think about it, I believe that maybe it was easier for me to skip the Stages of Grief, because while I accepted the fact that I did not have legs, I refused to accept that the loss of my legs was going to keep me down.
When I look at this experience, another thing that stands out to me are the blessings that I have experienced as a result of this incident. Again, it surprises many folks when I talk about how blessed I am daily, because when they look at me they see a cripple without legs, but when I look at myself, I see a man who has been blessed with a great life. Every day that I live is a blessing and a gift, because according to the doctors, I should not even be here.
I literally bled out five times over the first three days following the attack; as the doctors pumped blood into me as fast as I was pumping it out of me. Add to that the fact that over the summer while at Walter Reed, most of my major internal organs, heart, lungs, kidneys, stomach, and so on, decided to take a break and stop functioning for a period of time. Each one of these temporary organ failures ended me back down in the ICU. So, when I figure that I should have probably died a couple of times during this journey, every day that I’m alive is a gift.
Probably the next greatest blessing that stands out as a result of this experience is the absolute love and support of my family. I can honestly say that my lovely wife Alesia, and our three girls kept me fighting for my life. I honestly did not want to leave them; I didn’t want my wife to be without a husband or my daughters to be without a dad. My four girls really gave me the will to live, and I see each of them as a blessing sent straight from God.
Another blessing that has arisen from this challenging time in our life is that we have reconnected with many old friends. It is amazing that when something like this happens, friends from the past come out of the woodwork. I was surprised, as we spent the summer in Washington DC, how many friends that I had in that area. Now, as we’ve returned to Texas, and our unit has returned, we’ve been blessed by visits from so many friends.
If old friends are a blessing, new friends are another blessing. We have met so many really wonderful people as a result of my injuries. I have been honored to speak powerful national leaders, both military and civilian. But, I have also met some ordinary people with extraordinary kindness. If I hadn’t been hurt, I would have never met these people, so I count this as a blessing.
I tell you all this in the hopes of impressing upon you that life is precious, and it is a gift. While often times it is hard, we are still far better off seeing our lives as a series of blessing. We can choose, our attitude is our own. So, ask yourself, do you want to face challenges head on and make the most of them, or do you want to wallow in self pity when life throws you a curveball.
I cannot imagine how difficult it is to be a teenager today. I know that it has gotten harder since I was one. But I also figure that none of you can imagine how difficult it is to have no legs. So, if I can get through this challenge and keep a positive attitude, you can get through your challenges, and keep a positive attitude. There is really nothing special about me.
In closing, I would just like to ask you all to understand that life is going to present you with some challenges. Some of the things that you consider challenges will be minor compared to what I am going through, but some of you are actually liable to face even more significant challenges than what I’ve just spoke with you about. I would simply ask you to remember, as you face these challenges, that your attitude is your choice. I can tell you that a positive attitude makes life a whole lot more enjoyable than sitting around wallowing in self pity.
Thank you all for having me here tonight. I hope that you enjoyed my story as much as I have enjoyed spending time with you all tonight. God Bless you all.
« Close It